I had dinner with a couple friends last night and we got to talking about charities; what charities we’re involved in, why we chose them, etc. It turned into an interesting conversation that sparked some questions about value creation and if our charitable activities, or the charities themselves, created value. My friends wanted to know why, given a finite amount of resources, I chose to give time and money to a charity that helps animals instead of one that helps people, and thus creates societal and perhaps economic value. They couldn’t understand why, when I’m able to dedicate resources to any charity I want, I would choose a non-people one!
Background: I’m incredibly passionate about animals, so I’m involved with PAWS Chicago, an organization that strives to eliminate the destruction of homeless pets in Chicago. They run a spay/neuter clinic to reduce the number of homeless pets in the city and pull thousands of homeless animals from Chicago Animal Care & Control (where, after a period of time, they will be euthanized) and bring them to their Adoption Center in hopes of finding them “forever homes.” They take in all breeds of dogs and cats and provide them with food, water, love and shelter when they’re literally, on their last legs.
I can understand my friends’ position and I think the following example illustrates their point well: let’s say I have X minutes of time in my life to dedicate to charitable activities and I choose to use that time to mentor a disadvantaged child. That child becomes a good student, graduates from high school, goes to college, gets a job and becomes a “contributing” member of society. Have I created economic value by donating time to that child? My friends think so.
Now let’s say I donate that same time to an animal related charity that helps find homes for homeless pets. If a homeless animal is nursed back to health and placed in a happy, loving home, have I created economic value? I don’t know?
Dogs and cats will never hold jobs, or pursue research that benefits society, so I guess this becomes a larger question, what value do animals bring to people’s lives that justifies large, not-for-profit organizations be built up around their care and survival?
I love animals, I can’t help it. And the above conversation with my friends hasn’t deterred me from continuing to donate time and money to PAWS, but it did make me think, and um, write this blog post! I’d love to hear how you feel about it. Please comment below.
Learn more about PAWS at pawschicago.org.